out that。 then she got up； and； interrupting jane in the middle of a sentence； said：
“before you say any more； i want to know—am i to stay in the room？ because；” she added； “i have to confess that i am an impure woman。”
everyone looked at her in astonishment。
“you are going to have a baby？” asked jane。
she nodded her head。
it was extraordinary to see the different expressions on their faces。 a sort of hum went through the room； in which i could catch the words “impure；” “baby；” “castalia；” and so on。 jane； who was herself considerably moved； put it to us：
“shall she go？ is she impure？”
such a roar filled the room as might have been heard in the street outside。
“no！ no！ no！ let her stay！ impure？ fiddlesticks！” yet i fancied that some of the youngest； girls of nineteen or twenty； held back as if overe with shyness。 then we all came about her and began asking questions； and at last i saw one of the youngest； who had kept in the background； approach shyly and say to her：
“what is chastity then？ i mean is it good； or is it bad； or is it nothing at all？” she replied so low that i could not catch what she said。
“you know i was shocked；” said another； “for at least ten minutes。”
“in my opinion；” said poll； who was growing crusty from always reading in the london library； “chastity is nothing but ignorance—a most discreditable state of mind。 we should admit only the unchaste to our society。 i vote that castalia shall be our president。”
this was violently disputed。
“it is as unfair to brand women with chastity as with unchastity；” said poll。 “some of us haven’t the opportunity either。 moreover； i don’t believe cassy herself maintains that she acted as she did from a pure love of knowledge。”
“he is only twenty–one and divinely beautiful；” said cassy； with a ravishing gesture。
“i move；” said helen； “that no one be allowed to talk of chastity or unchastity save those who are in love。”
“oh； bother；” said judith； who had been enquiring into scientific matters； “i’m not in love and i’m longing to explain my measures for dispensing with prostitutes and fertilizing virgins by act of parliament。”
she went on to tell us of an invention of hers to be erected at tube stations and other public resorts； which； upon payment of a small fee； would safeguard the nation’s health； acmodate its sons； and relieve its daughters。 then she had contrived a method of preserving in sealed tubes the germs of future lord chancellors “or poets or painters or musicians；” she went on； “supposing； that is to say； that these breeds are not extinct； and that women still wish to bear children—”
“of course we wish to bear children！” cried castalia； impatiently。 jane rapped the table。
“that is the very point we are met to consider；” she said。 “for five years we have been trying to find out whether we are justified in continuing the human race。 castalia has anticipated our decision。 but it remains for the rest of us to make up our minds。”
here one after another of our messengers rose and delivered their reports。 the marvels of civilisation far exceeded our expectations； and； as we learnt for the first time how man flies in the air； talks across space； penetrates to the heart of an atom； and embraces the universe in his speculations； a murmur of admiration burst from our lips。
“we are proud；” we cried； “that our mothers sacrificed their youth in such a cause as this！” castalia； who had been listening intently； looked prouder than all the rest。 then jane reminded us that we had still much to learn； and castalia begged us to make haste。 on we went through a vast tangle of statistics。 we learnt that england has a population of so many millions； and that such and such a proportion of them is constantly hungry and in prison； that the average size of a working man’s family is such； and that so great a percentage of women die from maladies incident to childbirth。 reports were read of visits to factories； shops； slums； and dockyards。 descriptions were given of the stock exchange； of a gigantic house of business in the city； and of a government office。 the british colonies were now discussed； and some account was given of our rule in india； africa and ireland。 i was sitting by castalia and i noticed her uneasiness。
“we shall never e to any conclusion at all at this rate；” she said。 “as it appears that civilisation is so much more plex than we had any notion； would it not be better to confine ourselves to our original enquiry？ we agreed that it was the object of life to produce good people and good books。 all this time we have been talking of aeroplanes； factories； and money。 let us talk about men themselves and their arts； for that is the heart of the matter。”
so the diners out stepped forward with long slips of paper containing answers to their questions。 these had been framed after much consideration。 a good man； we had agreed； must at any rate be honest； passionate； and unworldly。 but whether or not a particular man possessed those qualities could only be discovered by asking questions； often beginning at a remote distance from the centre。 is kensington a nice place to live in？ where is your son being educated—and your daughter？ now please tell me； what do you pay for your cigars？ by the way； is sir joseph a baronet or only a knight？ often it seemed that we learnt more from trivial questions of this kind than from more direct ones。 “i accepted my peerage；” said lord bunkum； “because my wife wished it。” i forget how many titles were accepted for the same reason。 “working fifteen hours out of the twenty–four； as i do—” ten thousand professional men began。
“no； no； of course you can neither read nor write。 but why do you work so hard？” “my dear lady； with a growing family—” “but why does your family grow？” their wives wished that too； or perhaps it was the british empire。 but more significant than the answers were the refusals to answer。 very few would reply at all to questions about morality and religion； and such answers as were given were not serious。 questions as to the value of money and power were almost invariably brushed aside； or pressed at extreme risk to the asker。 “i’m sure；” said jill； “that if sir harley tightboots hadn’t been carving the mutton when i asked him about the capitalist system he would have cut my throat。 the only reason why we escaped with our lives over and over again is that men are at once so hungry and so chivalrous。 they despise us too much to mind what we say。”
“of course they despise us；” said eleanor。 “at the same time how do you account for this—i made enquiries among the artists。 now； no woman has ever been an artist； has she； polls？”
“jane—austen—charlotte—bronte—george—eliot；” cried poll； like a man crying muffins in a back street。
“damn the woman！” someone exclaimed。 “what a bore she is！”
“since sappho there has been no female of first rate—” eleanor began； quoting from a weekly newspaper。
“it’s now well known that sappho was the somewhat lewd invention of professor hobkin；” ruth interrupted。
“anyhow； there is no reason to suppose that any woman ever has been able to write or ever will be able to write；” eleanor continued。 “and yet； whenever i go among authors they never cease to talk to me about their books。 masterly！ i say； or shakespeare himself！ （for one must say something） and i assure you； they believe me。”
“that proves nothing；” said jane。 “they all do it。 only；” she sighed； “it doesn’t seem to help us much。 perhaps we had better examine modern literature next。 liz； it’s your turn。”
elizabeth rose and said that in order to prosecute her enquiry she had dressed as a man and been taken for a reviewer。
“i have read new books pretty steadily for the past five years；” said she。 “mr。 wells is the most popular living writer； then es mr。 arnold bennett； then mr。 pton makenzie； mr。 mckenna and mr。 walpole may be bracketed together。” she sat down。
“but you’ve told us nothing！” we expostulated。 “or do you mean that these gentlemen have greatly surpassed jane–elliot and that english fiction is—where’s that review of yours？ oh； yes； ‘safe in their hands。’”
“safe； quite safe；” she said； shifting uneasily from foot to foot。 “and i’m sure that they give away even more than they receive。”
we were all sure of that。 “but；” we pressed her； “do they write good books？”
“good books？” she said； looking at the ceiling “you must remember；” she began； speaking with extreme rapidity； “that fiction is the mirror of life。 and you can’t deny that education is of the highest importance； and that it would be extremely annoying； if you found yourself alone at brighton late at night； not to know which was the best boarding house to stay at； and suppose it was a dripping sunday evening—wouldn’t it be nice to go to the movies？”
“but what has that got to do with it？” we asked。
“nothing—nothing—nothing whatever；” she replied。
“well； tell us the truth；” we bade her。
“the truth？ but isn’t it wonderful；” she broke off—“mr。 chitter has written a weekly article for the past thirty years upon love or hot but